Pies and Cakes

Order a custom pie or cake in the store! Call us at (815) 459-9117 to order one today, Wednesday – Sunday 11am-9pm.

Custom Cakes

CAKE ROLL: Treat yourself to an old fashioned dessert. Chocolate or Yellow Cake layered with your choice of our rich Chocolate or creamy Vanilla Custard, then rolled up and frosted with Milk Chocolate Fudge. Serves 6-8

8-INCH ROUND CAKE: Our classic and most popular cake, allows you to create the perfect dessert for any occasion. Each cake contains two layers of cake, two layers of frozen custard, a layer of nuts, fruit, candy, or fudge, and is frosted with our vanilla frozen custard. If ordering in advance it may be possible to select a flavor of the day flavor to your cake. Serves 10-12

8 X 12 CAKE: Same concept as the 8-inch round, we just super-size it so you can share. Serves 24-36. Delicious PIES serves 8 (that’s only if you choose to share)

Frozen Custard Cake

Cake Slices

Cake Roll

Classic Pies

OREO FUDGE PIE: Indulge yourself in two layers of Oreo Cookie Custard, separated by a thick layer of Milk Chocolate Fudge topping, in an Oreo Cookie Pie Crust. I dare you to only have one slice.

TURTLE PIE: Caramel, Milk Chocolate Fudge, and loads of delicious Pecans sandwiched between two layers of Vanilla Custard in a Graham Cracker Crust are what make this pie a customer favorite!

SNICKER PIE: Love peanuts? Then we make this just for you! First we take Caramel, Milk Chocolate Fudge Topping and TONS of Peanuts and introduce them to each other. Once acquainted we put this winning combination between two layers of Vanilla Custard in a Graham Cracker Crust. Good luck saving any for later.

HEATH ALMOND FUDGE PIE: Crunchy Heath Bar Candy, Milk Chocolate Fudge, and Almonds all in one pie? I don’t mind if I do! We layer it all between two layers of Vanilla Custard in a Chocolate Pie Crust.

REESE’S PEANUT BUTTER CUP PIE: You might want to tell your taste buds to sit down before you throw this one at em… just a thought. We blend oodles and oodles of Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups with creamy Vanilla Custard and then throw a thick layer of rich Milk Chocolate Fudge topping in the middle. Made with a Graham Cracker Crust and finished with Whip Cream.
Tasty SUPREMES mini serves 2, medium serves 6-8, large serves 10-12

Burgundy Cherry Pie

Oreo Fudge Pie

Snicker Pie

Turtle Pie

Awesome Supremes

OREO FUDGE SUPREME: Don’t like cake? Don’t like crust? Well then sit back, relax, and enjoy Oreos, more Oreos, Milk Chocolate Fudge, and your choice of Chocolate or Vanilla Custard layered together to form absolute confectionery bliss!

TURTLE SUPREME: Our famous Turtle sundae served or dished out family-style. Layers of Fudge, Caramel, Pecans, and Vanilla Custard topped off with a cherry in the center. A true classic!

BROWNIE SUPREME: Brownie à la mode anyone? The Brownie Supreme is served with a layer of fresh brownies from a local bakery, Fudge, and who can forget the à la mode… Vanilla Custard! Finished off with Whip Cream and a Chocolate Drizzle.

DRUMSTICK SUPREME: Why not develop a cake from a summer treat staple (or ice cream truck favorite), the Drumstick? Reliving childhood memories one bite at a time. We layer Waffle Cone Pieces, Chocolate Drizzle, Milk Chocolate Fudge, Chopped Nuts, and Vanilla Custard. This pie would have made artist Jackson Pollock proud!