We make the same flavor base as we do our Butter Pecan flavor, but instead layer in chopped Heath Toffee pieces.

For this peanut butter lover’s flavor, we start with a vanilla base to which we add peanuts, Reese’s peanut butter cups, a peanut butter swirl, and a swirl of rich chocolate variegate.

This flavor has been around since the store first opened in 1985! We still layer in those same black bordeaux cherries into that classic cherry custard and the result is the best cherry flavor around.