Home > Cakes and Pies

CAKE AND PIE MENU

Cake Menu

Monster Mash Cookie Dough Cake

This cake features a made-in-house M&M's Oatmeal Cookie Dough that we layer with Chocolate Cookie Crumble (also made in house) to make a layered cake like no other. Layers of Peanut Butter and Vanilla Swirled Custard and Chocolate Custard bring together everyone's favorite flavor combination.

Strawberry Chocolate Cake

This cake Valentine's special features chocolate cake baked by our friends at Konrad's Bakery in Lakewood, IL. We layer it with strawberry custard and a fudge border. There is room on top to write a message.

Strawberry Confetti Cake

Perfect for parties! This cake features confetti cake baked by our friends at Konrad's Bakery in Lakewood, IL. We layer it with vanilla custard, whipped cream, and our very own made-in-house confetti cookie dough sprinkled on top. There is room on top to write a message. Enjoy our newest and tallest cake yet.

The Layered Chocolate Cake

Perfect for parties! This cake features chocolate cake baked by our friends at Konrad's Bakery in Lakewood, IL. We layer it with chocolate custard, chocolate ganache, fudge, and a cherry on top. Enjoy our newest chocolate obsession.

Confetti Cookie Dough Cake

Classic Birthday Cake

We have been making this cake since 1985! It is layers of cake, hot fudge, and custard that will make any birthday very special. We then frost it in vanilla custard and top it off with whipped cream and cherries. Inscription friendly.

The Friendly Chocolate Cake (dairy free, gluten free)

Why do we call this The Friendly Chocolate Cake you ask? It's because this tasty treat is completely vegan, but tastes amazing. It's double chocolate cookie crumble crust is delicious and sandwiches our double origin chocolate dairy free coconut cream "custard".

Turtle Supreme Cake

Salty pecans, sweet caramel, and rich chocolate ganache are sandwiched between layers of vanilla custard.

Ethereal Red Raspberry Cake

This cool cake features a single origin chocolate from Honduras made by our friends at Ethereal Chocolates in Woodstock, IL. Chocolate and vanilla custard is layered with seedless raspberry preserves and our homemade cookie crumble crust provides a crunchy foundation for this decadent dessert.

Salted Caramel Cocoa Crumble Cake

Homemade chocolate cookie crumble and a thin layer of chocolate custard, topped with a vanilla custard mixed with salted caramel and chocolate cookie crumble.

Cocoa Luxe Cake

Dense chocolate cake, rich chocolate ganache, and our homemade chocolate cookie crumble layered with chocolate and vanilla custard.

Learn More About our Cakes

Our cakes are made to order from fresh frozen custard and baked ingredients. Give us about 4-days to make them. Preorder now and pay when you pickup. They travel for at least 20 minutes, so bring a cooler on hotter days. They feed 6 to 10 people depending on size. We have dairy and dairy free options available. Keep frozen until you are ready to serve, thaw for 20 minutes, then slice with a knife and serve.

Pie Menu

Double Dribble Pie

Chocolate and Vanilla custard layered with fudge and caramel in a Oreo crust.

Oreo Fudge Pie

Cookies and Cream custard and Fudge in a chocolate cookie crust.

Peanut Butter Cup Pie

Peanut butter cup custard layered with fudge and peanut butter in a chocolate cookie crust.

Turtle Pie

Vanilla custard layered with fudge, caramel, and pecans in a graham cracker crust.

We are a family owned and operated frozen custard shop serving the McHenry County area. We are dedicated to providing fresh and locally produced flavors, sundaes, shakes, affogatos, and concretes.

LOCATION

SPRING HOURS

We are located at 6500 NW HWY, in Crystal Lake, IL. We are located next to the IHOP, across the street from Walgreens and CVS in the Plaza.