Peanut butter cup custard makes up the bottom and top layers of this pie, with a middle filling of fudge, peanut butter, and peanut butter cups. Our peanut butter cup pies are made in a chocolate cookie crust and decorated with a whipped cream border and a fudge/peanut butter/peanut butter cup garnish.
Peanut Butter Cup Pie
Peanut Butter Cup Pie
Size
9" (Serves 6 to 8)
Layers
- Peanut Butter and Chocolate Ganache Drizzle
- Whipped Cream Border
- Peanut Butter Cup Custard
- Peanut Butter Cups
- Peanut Butter
- Fudge
- Peanut Butter Cup Custard
- Chocolate Cookie Crust
Contains gluten; can be made gluten-free upon request.
Regular price
$26.00
Sale price
$26.00
Regular price
Shipping calculated at checkout.
Couldn't load pickup availability
Storage and Handling
Storage and Handling
Our frozen custard pies and cakes should be kept frozen until 15-minutes before serving. Some find it easy to run a butcher's knife under hot water between cuts.
Payment & Security
Payment methods
Your payment information is processed securely. We do not store credit card details nor have access to your credit card information.
Why our desserts taste different
Every pie and cake starts with fresh frozen custard made in our specialty custard machine, featuring a long stainless steel barrel designed to create an extra-dense and creamy texture. Each dessert is then placed in our hard-working hardening cabinets, held at –30 degrees, to lock in every layer and deliver a remarkably fresh, smooth texture you won’t find anywhere else.
Other Cakes and Pies
Cake & Pie FAQs
Can you ship?
Can you ship?
Unfortunately, at this time we do not ship orders. We only have pickup from our shop at 6500 NW HWY, Unit A, Crystal Lake, IL 60014.
Can I customize my cake or pie?
Can I customize my cake or pie?
Yes, we allow for customization of pies and cakes. We allow for customized messaging on some items (based on how it is made not all). Please note that the addition of extra toppings may incur a charge.
Can I talk to a cake maker?
Can I talk to a cake maker?
Absolutely, call us from 9am to 4pm Monday through Friday to ask cake or bulk related questions.
How do I store and serve the cake or pie?
How do I store and serve the cake or pie?
Keep frozen until 15-minutes before serving. This will allow time for the dessert to thaw and make it easier to cut. Thicker layer cakes or birthday cakes may take longer.
How fast can I get my cake or pie?
How fast can I get my cake or pie?
Our cakes can take up to 3-business days to be made, so if you need it faster, you'll have to call to see if we can get it done or choose from a great selection our freezer. Staff can put an option aside for your pickup date.
When can I pickup my cake or pie?
When can I pickup my cake or pie?
You'll chose a pickup date that you can change anytime. Keep in mind that these cakes can take up to 3-business days to be made, so plan accordingly. We have a well-stocked freezer, so call ahead and we can put one aside for you.
Picking up a cake or pie?
We have rock-hard cakes and pies from our well-maintained freezers. This map shows the recommended pickup radius for transporting cakes and pies from our shop while keeping them frozen during the hottest part of summer. Within this area, our large insulated bags help your order stay frozen on the drive home and ready for your freezer.
For longer trips, many customers bring a cooler with ice or dry ice. We also offer large insulated bags for purchase at the shop. Dry ice is readily available at local grocery stores, including Jewel.
